Oven Baked Paw'some Peanut Butter Cookie Dog Treats
Verified Jun 3, 2026
These crunchy baked dog treats use oats and peanut butter as the main ingredients, providing a simple, limited-ingredient option for most adult dogs. They’re relatively low in fat for a cookie-style treat and about 19 calories per piece, which can help with portion control during training or daily treating. The recipe avoids wheat, corn, and soy, and is made with just seven ingredients, which may appeal if you prefer a shorter, more straightforward ingredient list.
This is a nicely formulated crunchy biscuit treat with a short ingredient list centered around oats and peanut butter, suitable for most healthy dogs as an occasional reward. The moderate calorie content per treat is helpful if you’re watching your dog’s weight and want an easy number to work with. As with all treats, it should make up only a small percentage of the overall diet so your dog still gets complete and balanced nutrition from their main food.
The KibbleLab Score (1–10) is assessed from publicly available product data. Our evaluation is science-based, not marketing-based.
KibbleLab may earn an affiliate commission when you buy through a link. No one can pay for a higher score, or to change what we recommend for your pet.
At a Glance
KibbleLab Review
Strengths
- Simple, limited-ingredient recipe (oats, oat fiber, peanut butter as core ingredients) which can be easier to manage for dogs without multiple food sensitivities.
- Moderate calorie content at about 19 calories per treat, which makes portion control more straightforward for training or frequent rewards.
- Lower fat level (minimum 5% as fed) compared with many cookie-style treats, which can be helpful for dogs that don’t need extra dietary fat.
- Free from wheat, corn, and soy, and made without artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives, which some owners prefer to avoid.
Considerations
- Contains peanut butter and dried whey (a dairy ingredient), which will not be appropriate for dogs with peanut or dairy allergies or sensitivities.
- Oat-based, cookie-style treats are relatively high in carbohydrates, so they should be used sparingly for dogs that need strict weight control or have conditions where extra carbs are a concern.
- Not a complete and balanced diet; it should only be a small part of your dog’s daily calories, with the main nutrition coming from a balanced dog food.
Full Ingredient List
Ingredients and analysis reflect manufacturer data at the time of our last update and can change without notice. Always check the actual product packaging before feeding.
Ingredient filtering helps identify compatible options but is not a substitute for a veterinary elimination diet.
Top 5 Ingredients Explained
01
Oat
Oats are commonly used in pet foods as a digestible carbohydrate and source of soluble fiber (beta‑glucans), plant protein, B vitamins and minerals, which can support healthy digestion and help moderate blood glucose and cholesterol. They are generally well tolerated by dogs and can be included sparingly for cats, but owners should avoid flavored or sweetened preparations (and ingredients like xylitol or raisins), be mindful of possible grain sensitivities or cross‑contamination with gluten, and prefer cooked oats for better digestibility and portion control due to caloric content.
02
Oat Fiber
Oat fiber is used in pet foods primarily as an insoluble dietary fiber and bulking/texturizing ingredient to improve kibble structure, increase stool bulk, and promote feelings of fullness. It is generally well tolerated by dogs and cats and can support healthy digestion and weight management, but provides little protein or fat and in high amounts may dilute nutrient density or affect stool consistency, so formulations should be balanced and pets with rare oat sensitivities or cross‑contamination concerns monitored.
03
Peanut Butter
Peanut butter is commonly used as a palatability enhancer or occasional treat in pet diets, providing concentrated fats, modest protein, some fiber and micronutrients like vitamin E and B vitamins. Because it is calorie-dense and can contain added salt, sugar or harmful sweeteners, it should be offered sparingly and only in xylitol‑free formulations — avoid regular use in pets prone to obesity or pancreatitis.
04
Whey
Whey is a dairy-derived protein and flavoring commonly used in pet foods and treats as a highly digestible, high-quality protein source rich in essential amino acids (including branched-chain amino acids) and some minerals and B vitamins. It can support muscle maintenance and improve palatability for dogs and cats, but may cause gastrointestinal upset in lactose-intolerant animals and should be avoided in pets with milk allergies or used cautiously to prevent excess calories or mineral imbalance.
05
Canola Oil
Canola oil is used in pet foods as a concentrated fat source and palatability enhancer that supplies energy and essential fatty acids—mainly omega‑6 (linoleic acid) and some omega‑3 (ALA)—and aids absorption of fat‑soluble vitamins. It can support skin and coat condition when balanced with animal fats or supplemental omega‑3s, but is calorie‑dense so must be portioned to avoid weight gain, does not provide species‑specific fats such as arachidonic acid for cats, and must be kept fresh to prevent oxidation.
Nutritional Breakdown
How to read As Fed versus Dry Matter
As fed shows the numbers straight off the label, water included. Dry matter removes the water so you can compare a wet food and a dry food fairly.What is calorie density
How many calories the food packs per unit. Denser foods mean smaller portions for the same calories.Product Details & Brand
Product Specs
Brand
Merrick offers premium dog and cat food made with real, whole ingredients and regional produce. The brand is known for its recipes such as 'Grain Free', 'Backcountry', and 'Classic'. Merrick targets pet owners seeking natural and grain-free diets for their pets, with an emphasis on U.S.-sourced meats and fresh, farm-to-bowl ingredients.
Visit MerrickManufacturer
Merrick Pet Care manufactures its food in company-owned facilities in Hereford, Texas. The company maintains in-house quality control and safety testing, adhering to USDA, FDA, and AAFCO standards. Merrick emphasizes locally sourced ingredients and audits suppliers for quality and safety.
Manufacturing details are compiled from public sources and not independently verified; they may not reflect contract manufacturing or co-packing.
Recall History
Merrick Oven Baked Paw'some Peanut Butter Cookie Dog Treats has no recalls since 2014.
Source: FDA Pet Food Recall Database · Monitored daily
Sign up for the full picture
Feeding Calculator
Personalized portion sizes based on your pet's weight, age, and activity level.
Get started
Post your dog's report card and challenge friends to check their food.
Frequently Asked Questions
Has Merrick ever been recalled?
We have no recalls on record for Merrick. We monitor the FDA Pet Food Recall Database daily.
How does KibbleLab rate foods?
Our scores are based on ingredient composition, nutritional profile, AAFCO compliance, and health considerations. We don't penalize by-products, grains, or synthetic preservatives. Brands cannot pay for higher scores.
Is KibbleLab a substitute for veterinary advice?
No. KibbleLab provides data-driven food analysis, not medical advice. Always consult your veterinarian before making dietary changes, especially for pets with health conditions.
KibbleLab provides informational content only. This is not veterinary advice. Always consult a qualified veterinarian before changing your pet's diet.
KibbleLab may earn affiliate commissions through product links. No one can pay for a higher score, or to change what we recommend for your pet.
Product data sourced from manufacturer websites, AAFCO statements, and FDA recall database. Last verified dates reflect our most recent data check.
Continue with Google
Continue with Facebook