Skip to content

7,500+ pet foods rated. Your best match, free in 30 seconds.

Back
Peanut Butter, Pumpkin & Papaya Hearty Selects Treats
Finley's

Peanut Butter, Pumpkin & Papaya Hearty Selects Treats

Verified Aug 30, 2026

Dog · Treat All Breed Sizes

A plant-based, limited-ingredient dog treat made with oats, potatoes, peas, and peanut butter as the main calorie sources. Pumpkin, papaya, and flaxseed add fiber and some natural nutrients, making this a flavorful training or reward option rather than a balanced diet. With about 19 calories per piece, it’s a relatively calorie-dense snack, so portions matter especially for smaller or less active dogs.

Jump to ingredients
Over-the-counter Pet Sustainability Coalition Accredited No recalls

Affiliate link · may earn a commission at no extra cost to you

Official product page
KibbleLab Score
8.8 out of 10

Strong Choice

This is a thoughtfully formulated, wheat-, corn-, and soy-free treat that relies on plant ingredients and peanut butter rather than meat. It’s best used as an occasional reward or training treat for dogs who tolerate oats, peas, and peanut butter well. The calorie density means it can contribute more to daily intake than some owners realize, so it should be fed in moderation and balanced against your dog’s regular food.

Calorie and portion clarity 10.0
Ingredient composition 6.5
Health considerations 10.0

Computed from 3 of 3 applicable checks. Missing data is skipped, never counted against a food.

The KibbleLab Score (1–10) is assessed from publicly available product data. Our evaluation is science-based, not marketing-based.

Nutritional profile Protein, fat, fiber on a dry-matter basis, for the stated life stage and format
Adequacy substantiation Complete and balanced substantiation; feeding trials valued higher
Ingredient composition Screened for unnamed sources, artificial additives, and label protein inflation. Not a quality ranking.
Health considerations Pulse-heavy grain-free (DCM) pattern and recall history
Verified manufacturer evidence A small bonus when we can verify evidence addressing WSAVA selection criteria
9.0 - 10 Top Pick
8.0 - 8.9 Strong Choice
7.0 - 7.9 Solid Option
6.0 - 6.9 Worth a Conversation
Below 6.0 Review Carefully

KibbleLab may earn an affiliate commission when you buy through a link. No one can pay for a higher score, or to change what we recommend for your pet.


At a Glance

Marketed Benefits
Where these benefits come from Benefits the manufacturer highlights in its own product marketing. KibbleLab lists them for reference and does not verify these claims.
High Energy
Diet & Compliance
Limited Ingredient
Suitable For
All Breed Sizes
Does this food work for your pet?
We'll check every ingredient against your pet's sensitivities and avoidance list.

Nutritional Perspective

KibbleLab Review

Strengths

  • Uses simple, limited ingredients, which can be helpful for dogs who do better with a shorter ingredient list.
  • Peanut butter, oats, and peas provide a decent amount of plant-based protein and energy for active dogs.
  • Includes pumpkin, papaya, and flax seed, which add fiber and some natural phytonutrients.
  • Free from wheat, corn, and soy, which may suit dogs who need to avoid those particular ingredients.

Considerations

  • This is a treat only and not a complete and balanced diet, so it should not replace your dog’s main food.
  • At about 19 calories per piece, it can add up quickly for small or less active dogs if overfed.
  • Peas are a main carbohydrate source, so owners avoiding pulse-heavy foods for personal reasons may want to limit total exposure.
  • Contains peanut butter, so it is not suitable for dogs with peanut allergies or known sensitivities to legumes.
Scored using the rubric of an NAVC Certified Pet Nutrition Coach (PNCC). This is informational, not veterinary advice.

Full Ingredient List

oats, potatoes, peas, coconut glycerin, cane molasses, peanut butter, pumpkin, papaya, flax seed, natural flavor, apple cider vinegar, salt, distilled vinegar, turmeric, sunflower lecithin, tocopherols (a preservative), rosemary extract

Ingredients and analysis reflect manufacturer data at the time of our last update and can change without notice. Always check the actual product packaging before feeding.

Ingredient filtering helps identify compatible options but is not a substitute for a veterinary elimination diet.

Top 5 Ingredients Explained

01
Oat
Oats are commonly used in pet foods as a digestible carbohydrate and source of soluble fiber (beta‑glucans), plant protein, B vitamins and minerals, which can support healthy digestion and help moderate blood glucose and cholesterol. They are generally well tolerated by dogs and can be included sparingly for cats, but owners should avoid flavored or sweetened preparations (and ingredients like xylitol or raisins), be mindful of possible grain sensitivities or cross‑contamination with gluten, and prefer cooked oats for better digestibility and portion control due to caloric content.
View ingredient
02
Potato
Potato is commonly used in pet foods as a digestible carbohydrate source and functional binder, supplying starch, fiber, and modest amounts of vitamins (B6, C) and potassium—often included as cooked or dehydrated flakes, starch, or protein concentrates. While it provides energy and helps formulate grain‑free recipes, potatoes are not a primary protein for dogs or cats (and are not nutritionally required for obligate‑carnivore cats), can contribute to excess calories or affect blood glucose in diabetic animals, and must be cooked and free of green skins or sprouts to avoid solanine toxicity; allergies are uncommon but possible.
View ingredient
03
Pea
Pea is a plant-based ingredient used in pet foods as a source of protein, soluble and insoluble fiber, and micronutrients (often included as whole peas, pea flour, or pea protein concentrate) to boost protein content and improve texture. While peas can provide digestible carbohydrates, fiber, and some plant protein useful especially for dogs, they are not a complete protein for obligate carnivores like cats and — when overused, particularly in concentrated forms or as a major component of grain‑free diets — have been scrutinized for a possible association with canine dilated cardiomyopathy and can contribute to nutrient imbalances or excess calories, so balanced formulation and compliance with AAFCO nutritional profiles are important.
View ingredient
04
Coconut Glycerin
Coconut glycerin is a plant-derived glycerol used in pet foods as a humectant and mild sweetening/texture agent to retain moisture, improve mouthfeel and palatability, and serve as a solvent or mild preservative in soft treats, toppers, and wet formulas. It provides easily metabolized calories and is generally safe for dogs and cats in small amounts, but high levels can cause gastrointestinal upset or laxative effects, so manufacturers should ensure purity, account for added calories, and note that it is not the dog-toxic sweetener xylitol.
05
Cane Molasses
Cane molasses is a viscous sweetener and palatability enhancer used in pet foods and treats to add simple carbohydrates, help bind ingredients, and contribute trace minerals like iron, calcium, potassium and magnesium along with small amounts of B vitamins. It can improve taste and texture but is high in sugars and calories, so it should be used sparingly—excessive intake can contribute to weight gain, dental issues, or unstable blood glucose in diabetic or obese pets.

Nutritional Breakdown

How to read As Fed versus Dry Matter As fed shows the numbers straight off the label, water included. Dry matter removes the water so you can compare a wet food and a dry food fairly.
As Fed
Crude Protein (min)
10.00%
Low High
Crude Fat (min)
4.50%
Low High
Crude Fiber (max)
6.00%
Low High
Moisture (max)
30.00%
Low High
3308
kcal / Kg
19
kcal / Treat
Moderate
Calorie density category
What is calorie density How many calories the food packs per unit. Denser foods mean smaller portions for the same calories.

Not sure how much of this to feed?

The right daily portion depends on your dog's weight, age, and activity level. Create a free account, add your dog, and get their daily calories and portion sizes.


Product Details & Brand

Product Specs

Breed size All Breed Sizes
Texture Whole Pieces
Food type Treat

Brand

Premium dog treats made without wheat, corn, soy, fillers, or chemical preservatives, sold under a mission that creates paid employment for people with disabilities. Founded in 2010 by Kyle and Angie Gallus, now owned by Tuffy's Treat Company.

Price tier $$$

Manufacturer

Company name Tuffy's Treat Company
Parent company KLN Family Brands
Headquarters Delano, Minnesota, USA
Manufacturing type In House
Manufacturing country United States
Manufacturing region Minnesota
Pet Sustainability Coalition Accredited business seal
Pet Sustainability Coalition Accredited

PSC is a nonprofit that Accredits pet companies on their environmental and social impact, through third-party verification. Tuffy's Treat Company is a PSC Accredited business. View profile

Manufacturing details are compiled from public sources and not independently verified; they may not reflect contract manufacturing or co-packing.

Recall History

No recalls on record

No recall is listed for Finley's Peanut Butter, Pumpkin & Papaya Hearty Selects Treats.

Source: FDA animal food recall listings back to January 2019 · Checked daily, last on Sep 1, 2026

Unlock More

Sign up for the full picture

Ingredient Check

We'll check every ingredient against your pet's profile.

Feeding Calculator

Personalized portion sizes based on your pet's weight, age, and activity level.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Compare this food with alternatives to find the best fit.


Share this food
KibbleLab food report
GREAT BOWL.
8.8 /10 Grade A
Peanut Butter, Pumpkin & Papaya Hearty Selects Treats
Finley's · kibblelab.com

Post your dog's report card and challenge friends to check their food.


Frequently Asked Questions

Has Finley's ever been recalled?

We have no recalls on record for Finley's. We track the FDA's animal food recall listings back to January 2019 and publish every pet food recall automatically. A filing that isn't pet food may not appear here.

How does KibbleLab rate foods?

Our scores are based on ingredient composition, nutritional profile, AAFCO compliance, and health considerations. We don't penalize by-products, grains, or synthetic preservatives. Brands cannot pay for higher scores.

Is KibbleLab a substitute for veterinary advice?

No. KibbleLab provides data-driven food analysis, not medical advice. Always consult your veterinarian before making dietary changes, especially for pets with health conditions.

What does YOUR pet eat?
Look up any dog or cat food. Free, takes 30 seconds, no sign-up.
Check a Food

KibbleLab provides informational content only. This is not veterinary advice. Always consult a qualified veterinarian before changing your pet's diet.

KibbleLab may earn affiliate commissions through product links. No one can pay for a higher score, or to change what we recommend for your pet.

Product data sourced from manufacturer websites, AAFCO statements, and FDA recall listings. Last verified dates reflect our most recent data check. We track the FDA's animal food recall listings back to January 2019 and publish every pet food recall automatically. A filing that isn't pet food may not appear here.