Skip to content

7,500+ pet foods rated. Your best match, free in 30 seconds.

Holistic Select vs Member's Mark

Holistic Select is made by Wellness Pet Company (owned by Clearlake Capital Group), and Member's Mark is branded by Sam's Club (owned by Walmart Inc.) and made by third-party co-packers. On KibbleLab, Member's Mark averages 8.9 out of 10 across its scored foods, compared with 8.6 for Holistic Select. Holistic Select is accredited by the Pet Sustainability Coalition; Member's Mark is not.

Holistic Select and Member's Mark compared

Holistic Select Member's Mark
Manufacturer Wellness Pet Company Sam's Club
Parent company Clearlake Capital Group Walmart Inc.
Founded 2021 1983
Headquarters Tewksbury, Massachusetts, USA Bentonville, Arkansas, USA
Manufacturing Whether a brand makes its own food in-house or has it produced by an outside contract manufacturer or co-packer.
In-house Co-packer
Made in United States United States
Manufacturing region Arkansas Not listed
Products listed 8 15
Serves Dogs Cats & dogs
Price tier A relative price guide, from $ (most affordable) to $$$$$ (most premium), based on the brand's typical retail cost.
$$$$ $$
WSAVA guidelines The World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA) publishes criteria for evaluating a manufacturer: qualified nutritionists on staff, feeding trials, and published research. It does not certify or endorse brands.
No No
PSC accredited The Pet Sustainability Coalition is a nonprofit that accredits pet companies on their environmental and social impact, through third-party verification. It reflects sustainability practices, not food quality.
Yes No
Score The average KibbleLab score across this brand's scored foods, on a 0 to 10 scale. Foods are scored on published veterinary science. How scoring works .
8.6 (avg of 8) 8.9 (avg of 15)
Recalls on record We track the FDA's animal food recall listings back to January 2019 and publish every pet food recall automatically. A filing that isn't pet food may not appear here.
None None
Where to buy
Amazon
Amazon

Affiliate links · may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Holistic Select vs Member's Mark: how they compare

Scores

Member's Mark scores higher on KibbleLab, averaging 8.9 out of 10 across 15 scored foods, compared with 8.6 across 8 for Holistic Select. Scores apply the same criteria-based rubric to every food, drawn from published veterinary science.

Who makes them

Holistic Select is made by Wellness Pet Company, owned by Clearlake Capital Group, based in Tewksbury, Massachusetts, USA, founded in 2021. Member's Mark is a brand of Sam's Club, owned by Walmart Inc., based in Bentonville, Arkansas, USA, founded in 1983. Its food is made by third-party co-packers in United States.

Standards and range

Neither meets WSAVA's published manufacturer criteria. Holistic Select is accredited by the Pet Sustainability Coalition; Member's Mark is not. KibbleLab lists 8 Holistic Select foods and 15 Member's Mark foods.

Not sure which is right for your pet?

Sign in free to save favorites and compare foods side by side. Add KL+ to see Holistic Select and Member's Mark scored for your pet's breed, age, and health focus.

Example foods

Common Questions

Which scores higher on KibbleLab, Holistic Select or Member's Mark?

Member's Mark scores higher: it averages 8.9 out of 10 across 15 scored foods, compared with 8.6 for Holistic Select. Scores reflect published veterinary science.

Who makes Holistic Select and Member's Mark?

Holistic Select is made by Wellness Pet Company, which is owned by Clearlake Capital Group. Member's Mark is a brand of Sam's Club, which is owned by Walmart Inc.. Its food is made by third-party co-packers in United States.

Which brand has more products on KibbleLab?

Member's Mark has 15 products in the KibbleLab database, compared with 8 for Holistic Select.

Where is each brand based?

Holistic Select is based in Tewksbury, Massachusetts, USA. Member's Mark is based in Bentonville, Arkansas, USA.

Are Holistic Select or Member's Mark PSC Accredited?

Holistic Select is a PSC Accredited business. The Pet Sustainability Coalition is a nonprofit that Accredits pet companies on their environmental and social impact, through third-party verification.

Have Holistic Select or Member's Mark been recalled?

Neither Holistic Select nor Member's Mark has a recall on record in the KibbleLab database. We track the FDA's animal food recall listings back to January 2019 and publish every pet food recall automatically. A filing that isn't pet food may not appear here.

See the full profiles: Holistic Select and Member's Mark .

More comparisons

KibbleLab provides informational content only. This is not veterinary advice. Always consult a qualified veterinarian before changing your pet's diet.

This is a neutral, factual comparison, not a ranking or an endorsement of either brand. KibbleLab may earn affiliate commissions through links. No one can pay for placement or a higher score.

Brand and manufacturer details are compiled from public sources and not independently verified; they may not reflect contract manufacturing or co-packing. Recall data is compiled from public FDA filings, and a filing may name the parent company rather than the brand. We track the FDA's animal food recall listings back to January 2019 and publish every pet food recall automatically. A filing that isn't pet food may not appear here.

KibbleLab scores and commentary are editorial opinions based on published data. Represent one of these brands? Request a correction. Anyone else can email us. See our Terms.